List:General Discussion« Previous MessageNext Message »
From:Noah Dowd Date:August 14 2007 1:36pm
Subject:RE: index, unique index question
View as plain text  
Of course, since James said he will never search for a record matching receiver_ID AND
sender_ID, it would be more efficient to simply create one index for each of the columns.


-----Original Message-----
From: Kristian Myllymäki [mailto:kristian@stripped] 
Sent: Tuesday, August 14, 2007 3:50 AM
To: Ananda Kumar
Cc: James Tu; MySQL List
Subject: Re: index, unique index question

A composite index on both columns may be used by queries involving  
either both columns, or the first column in the index.

So, an index on (receiver_id, sender_id) may be used by predicates on  
both columns or receiver_id alone, but never sender_id alone. (Or I  
should never say never, since mysql could in the future implement an  
index scan on the secondary column if the first has very few distinct  

Since James only uses the predicates alone and never combined, I would  
also suggest a secondary index on (sender_id).

unique index (receiver_id, sender_id)
index (sender_id)


Quoting Ananda Kumar <anandkl@stripped>:

> Hi James,
> Since your queries have both receiver_id and sender_id in the where
> condition and u want this to be unique, just create one combined unique
> index on both these columns.
> Do this at db level will give you much better options, performance, rather
> than doing at code level, which might involve quite bit of coding and will
> slow down the performance of the app.
> If you create individual index and combined index, there will be huge
> performance degradation as there would be unnecessary index over heads.
> regards
> anandkl
> On 8/14/07, James Tu <jtu@stripped> wrote:
>> I have a table that has a Primary key using the 'id' column.
>> The table also has a 'receiver_id' and a 'sender_id'.
>> I have queries that will use
>> (1) "WHERE receiver_id ="
>> or
>> (2) "WHERE sender_id="
>> but never "WHERE receiver_id='###' AND sender_id='###'"
>> Also, I want the receiver_id/sender_id pair to be unique.  The reason
>> I want this unique key is so that I can issue a
>> 'INSERT ... ON DUPLICATE KEY UPDATE' kind of query.
>> What's the best approach to create indices in this case?
>> (A) Create an index on 'receiver_id' and also create an index on
>> 'sender_id'
>> ...and enforce the uniqueness of receiver_id and sender_id in
>> code...first do a query to see if it's there then either do an UPDATE
>> or and INSERT.
>> or
>> (B) Create a unique index on the 'receiver_id' and 'sender_id' pair?
>> When I create both (A) and (B), phpmyadmin gives me a warning
>> indicating that more than one index is created on 'receiver_id.'
>> Any suggestions on how to handle this situation?
>> -James
>> --
>> MySQL General Mailing List
>> For list archives:
>> To unsubscribe:

MySQL General Mailing List
For list archives:
To unsubscribe:

index, unique index questionJames Tu14 Aug
  • Re: index, unique index questionAnanda Kumar14 Aug
    • Re: index, unique index questionKristian Myllymäki14 Aug
      • RE: index, unique index questionNoah Dowd14 Aug
    • Re: index, unique index questionMartijn Tonies14 Aug
      • Re: index, unique index questionAnanda Kumar14 Aug