List:General Discussion« Previous MessageNext Message »
From:Benjamin Pflugmann Date:January 5 2001 6:18pm
Subject:Re: MySQL 3.23.30-gamma
View as plain text  
Hi.

On Fri, Jan 05, 2001 at 04:33:54PM +0200, sinisa@stripped wrote:
[...]
> Yes, the above version of mysqldump will not work with 3.22 servers.
> 
> We could have put on our TODO to add an option for mysqldump to use
> 3.22 syntax, but then 3.23 is alrady a stable release, so the best
> solution for you is to upgrade.

Sorry, but I have to disagree.

It's not always possible to influence the server version (e.g. with a
provider hosting MySQL), therefore the correct behaviour IMHO would be
that mysqldump either offers a switch to be downwards compatible, or
even better, query the server version and behave accordingly.

Regardless of that, if newer mysqldumps cannot work with servers prior
to 3.23.x, they should query the server version and display an
appropriate error message, telling the user what to do (downgrading
mysqldump): Either be compatible or tell that you aren't.

An error message out of context like the one cited isn't reasonable,
in my opinion.

Bye,

        Benjamin.

Thread
Compiling Error! Please help!!!Pedro Inacio12 Mar
  • Re: Compiling Error! Please help!!!Thimble Smith12 Mar
  • Re: MySQL 3.23.30-gammaChristian Hammers5 Jan
    • Re: MySQL 3.23.30-gammaSinisa Milivojevic5 Jan
      • Re: MySQL 3.23.30-gammaBenjamin Pflugmann5 Jan
        • Re: MySQL 3.23.30-gammaChristian Hammers5 Jan
        • Re: MySQL 3.23.30-gammaBasil Hussain8 Jan
    • Re: MySQL 3.23.30-gammaMichael Widenius6 Jan
    • Re: MySQL 3.23.30-gammaMichael Widenius6 Jan
  • Re: MySQL 3.23.30-gammaT├Ánu Samuel6 Jan
  • compiling MySQL 3.23.3x on Cobalt RAQ2Harald Kapper23 Jan
Re: MySQL 3.23.30-gammaMichael Widenius7 Jan