List:General Discussion« Previous MessageNext Message »
From:Andrew Moore Date:May 23 2013 9:16pm
Subject:Re: Bug in BETWEEN same DATETIME
View as plain text  
Personally I don't share your view that it's a bug. Omitting the time
results in midnight by default so this screws between because there's no
time between 00:00:00 and 00:00:00.

Are you having operational issues here or are you simply fishing for bugs?

WHERE  `transaction_date` = DATE(datetime)
or
WHERE  `transaction_date` = (new column stored as date)





On Thu, May 23, 2013 at 9:55 PM, Daevid Vincent <daevid@stripped> wrote:

> I just noticed what I consider to be a bug; and related, has this been
> fixed
> in later versions of MySQL?
>
> We are using:
> mysql  Ver 14.12 Distrib 5.0.92, for portbld-freebsd8.1 (amd64) using  5.2
>
> If you use BETWEEN and the same date for both parts (i.e. you want a single
> day) it appears that the operator isn't smart enough to consider the full
> day in the cases where the column is a DATETIME
>
>
> http://dev.mysql.com/doc/refman/5.0/en/comparison-operators.html#operator_be
> tween
>
> WHERE `transaction_date` BETWEEN '2013-04-16' AND '2013-04-16'
>
> I actually have to format it like this to get results
>
> WHERE `transaction_date` BETWEEN '2013-04-16 00:00:00' AND '2013-04-16
> 11:59:59'
>
> As it appears that in the first instance it defaults the time to 00:00:00
> always, as verified by this:
>
> WHERE `transaction_date` BETWEEN '2013-04-16' AND '2013-04-16 11:59:59'
>
> So,  I think it's probably safe to assume that if someone is using the
> BETWEEN on datetime columns, their intent more often than not is to get the
> full 24 hour period, not the 0 seconds it currently pulls by default.
>
> I also tried these hacks as per the web page above, but this doesn't yield
> results either
>
> WHERE `transaction_date` BETWEEN CAST('2013-04-16' AS DATE) AND
> CAST('2013-04-16' AS DATE)
> WHERE `transaction_date` BETWEEN CAST('2013-04-16' AS DATETIME) AND
> CAST('2013-04-16' AS DATETIME)
>
> This one works, but I fail to see how it's any more beneficial than using a
> string without the CAST() overhead?
>
> WHERE `transaction_date` BETWEEN CAST('2013-04-16 00:00:00' AS DATETIME)
> AND
> CAST('2013-04-16 11:59:59' AS DATETIME)
>
> Or is there some other magical incantation that is supposed to be used
> (without me manually appending the time portion)?
>

Thread
Bug in BETWEEN same DATETIMEDaevid Vincent23 May
  • RE: Bug in BETWEEN same DATETIMETimothy R Peterson23 May
    • Re: Bug in BETWEEN same DATETIMEMichael Dykman23 May
      • RE: Bug in BETWEEN same DATETIMERick James23 May
  • Re: Bug in BETWEEN same DATETIMEAndrew Moore23 May
    • Re: Bug in BETWEEN same DATETIMEAndrew Moore23 May
  • Re: Bug in BETWEEN same DATETIMEshawn green23 May
    • RE: Bug in BETWEEN same DATETIMERick James23 May
      • Re: Bug in BETWEEN same DATETIMEshawn green24 May
        • RE: Bug in BETWEEN same DATETIMERick James24 May
          • Re: Bug in BETWEEN same DATETIMEshawn green24 May
        • Re: Bug in BETWEEN same DATETIMEhsv24 May
          • RE: Bug in BETWEEN same DATETIMERick James29 May