List:General Discussion« Previous MessageNext Message »
From:jeffrey_n_Dyke Date:October 28 2003 4:47pm
Subject:Re: Is MySQL Relational? (was: Foreigner keys in MySQL?)
View as plain text  
I tend to agree with the past two posts that mysql is in fact relational,
and would like to add that if we are going to make blanket statements that
something IS or IS NOT that we qualify our responses.  personlly i would
like to know why Martijn views it as being a non relational db, without
argument.  If you just say its so, why am is supposed to take that
statement over those that provide a full email of text like bluejack or
John that provided additional information via a link.

Just saying No, to a question like that does not lend to learning only to
confusion.

sorry about the mini rant....
jeff






                                                                                          
                                             
                      bluejack                                                            
                                             
                      <blunt@stripped        To:       mysql@stripped         
                                                
                      om>                      cc:                                     
                                                
                                               Subject:  Is MySQL Relational? (was:
Foreigner keys in MySQL?)                           
                      10/28/2003 11:38                                                    
                                             
                      AM                                                                  
                                             
                                                                                          
                                             
                                                                                          
                                             




10/28/03 8:11:16 AM, "Martijn Tonies" <m.tonies@stripped> wrote:

>>
>> If you are trying to determine whether MySQL is a relational database,
>> the answer is yes.
>
>Ehm... the answer is "no".
>
>It's getting better, that's for sure.

MySQL may or may not conform to some standard or another, and it may
or may not perform the tasks that you, personally, want it to, but
in fact it *is* a relational database, as opposed to a flat file or
an object database.

I recommended the questioner evaluate her needs against MySQL's
available feature set, because if you are used to Oracle (or some
other robust, commercial relational database) you may be surprised
at some of the differences or absences in MySQL.

But the questioner made it seem as though she was really just
trying to get a feel for the basics scope of MySQL, and in that
context, yes, MySQL is designed to a implement a relational
database model as opposed to some other fundamental type of
database.

So, what's your laundry list of things MySQL should do?

--bluejack



--
MySQL General Mailing List
For list archives: http://lists.mysql.com/mysql
To unsubscribe:    http://lists.mysql.com/mysql?unsub=1





Thread
Foreigner keys in MySQL?Juliana Gubert Ehrensperger28 Oct
  • RE: Foreigner keys in MySQL?Michael McTernan28 Oct
  • Re: Foreigner keys in MySQL?Peter Brawley28 Oct
  • Re: Foreigner keys in MySQL?bluejack28 Oct
    • Re: Foreigner keys in MySQL?Martijn Tonies28 Oct
      • Is MySQL Relational? (was: Foreigner keys in MySQL?)bluejack28 Oct
        • Re: Is MySQL Relational? (was: Foreigner keys in MySQL?)Martijn Tonies28 Oct
      • Re: Foreigner keys in MySQL?shrek-m@gmx.de28 Oct
RE: Foreigner keys in MySQL?John Griffin28 Oct
Re: Is MySQL Relational? (was: Foreigner keys in MySQL?)jeffrey_n_Dyke28 Oct
  • Re: Is MySQL Relational? (was: Foreigner keys in MySQL?)Saqib Ali28 Oct
RE: Is MySQL Relational? (was: Foreigner keys in MySQL?)Saqib Ali28 Oct
Re: Is MySQL Relational? (was: Foreigner keys in MySQL?)bluejack28 Oct
Re: Is MySQL Relational? (was: Foreigner keys in MySQL?)Heikki Tuuri28 Oct
  • RE: Is MySQL Relational? (was: Foreigner keys in MySQL?)Mike Brando28 Oct
    • Re: Is MySQL Relational? (was: Foreigner keys in MySQL?)Martijn Tonies29 Oct
Re: Is MySQL Relational? (was: Foreigner keys in MySQL?)Peter Brawley28 Oct
Re: Is MySQL Relational? (was: Foreigner keys in MySQL?)Martijn Tonies29 Oct