List:General Discussion« Previous MessageNext Message »
From:Michael T. Babcock Date:December 11 2002 3:22pm
Subject:Re: LEGAL information about MySQL. (troll?)
View as plain text  
On Wed, Dec 11, 2002 at 10:41:39AM +0200, Calin Pop wrote:
> I thing PROGRAM1 must be distributet under GPL but PROGRAM2 can be
> distributed with any license.

<RANT>
 <IANAL Comment="Lawyers get paid more than I do; call one">

I've given my interpretation before, and you should probably read it;
if you link against the mysql client library to connect to the server then
you're linking against GPL'd code and must GPL your program (or provide
at least the same rights as the GPL does and no less).  If you don't like
that and expect it to work as you mentionned, use the 3.2x.xx libraries
as they are LGPL'd (after a certain point, to my knowledge).  This allows
you to link against (but careful with distributing) them without GPL'ing
your product.

 </IANAL>

The _BEST_ link to read for this information is the text of the LGPL, since
it details why one would choose to use the LGPL over the GPL (or vice versa)
and you'll find that those reasons are the list of rights you want.  Read
especially the link "Why you shouldn't use the LGPL ..."

 * http://www.gnu.org/copyleft/lgpl.html
 * http://www.gnu.org/philosophy/why-not-lgpl.html

</RANT>

<SPAM TYPE=NOT NOTES=SQL, QUERY />
-- 
Michael T. Babcock
CTO, FibreSpeed Ltd.     (Hosting, Security, Consultation, Database, etc)
http://www.fibrespeed.net/~mbabcock/
Thread
LEGAL information about MySQL.Darney Lampert29 Nov
  • Re: LEGAL information about MySQL.Tonu Samuel30 Nov
  • Re: LEGAL information about MySQL.Pae Choi30 Nov
    • Re: LEGAL information about MySQL.Mark Matthews30 Nov
      • Re: [OT] LEGAL information about MySQL.Pae Choi30 Nov
        • Re: [OT] LEGAL information about MySQL.Tonu Samuel30 Nov
        • Re: [OT] LEGAL information about MySQL.Benjamin Pflugmann30 Nov
        • Re: [OT] LEGAL information about MySQL.David Axmark5 Dec
      • Re: [OT] LEGAL information about MySQL.Pae Choi30 Nov
        • Re: [OT] LEGAL information about MySQL.Tonu Samuel30 Nov
      • Re: [OT] LEGAL information about MySQL.Pae Choi30 Nov
      • Re: LEGAL information about MySQL.Michael T. Babcock2 Dec
      • Re: [OT] LEGAL information about MySQL.Pae Choi5 Dec
        • Re: [OT] LEGAL information about MySQL.David Axmark5 Dec
          • How to tell MySQL where to store db files ??Will Standley6 Dec
            • Re: How to tell MySQL where to store db files ??Roger Baklund6 Dec
            • re: How to tell MySQL where to store db files ??Victoria Reznichenko6 Dec
          • What are basic db files MySQL creates?Will Standley6 Dec
            • Re: What are basic db files MySQL creates?Roger Baklund6 Dec
              • RE: What are basic db files MySQL creates?Will Standley6 Dec
            • re: What are basic db files MySQL creates?Victoria Reznichenko6 Dec
            • Re: What are basic db files MySQL creates?iConnect \(Berlin\) Stefan Hinz6 Dec
  • Re: LEGAL information about MySQL.Pae Choi30 Nov
  • Re: LEGAL information about MySQL.Pae Choi30 Nov
    • Re: [OT] LEGAL information about MySQL.Benjamin Pflugmann30 Nov
    • Re: LEGAL information about MySQL.Mark Matthews30 Nov
  • Re: LEGAL information about MySQL.Pae Choi30 Nov
    • Re: LEGAL information about MySQL.David Axmark5 Dec
      • Re: LEGAL information about MySQL.Michael T. Babcock5 Dec
  • Re: [OT] LEGAL information about MySQL.Pae Choi30 Nov
    • Re: [OT] LEGAL information about MySQL.Benjamin Pflugmann30 Nov
      • Re: [OT] LEGAL information about MySQL.Darney Lampert2 Dec
        • Re: LEGAL information about MySQL.Benjamin Pflugmann2 Dec
        • Re: [OT] LEGAL information about MySQL.David Axmark5 Dec
          • RE: [OT] LEGAL information about MySQL.Rick Cronan5 Dec
    • Re: [OT] LEGAL information about MySQL.Mark5 Dec
  • Re: LEGAL information about MySQL.Calin Pop11 Dec
    • Re: LEGAL information about MySQL.Daniel Kiss11 Dec
    • Re: LEGAL information about MySQL. (troll?)Michael T. Babcock11 Dec
Re: LEGAL information about MySQL.Mark30 Nov
  • Re: LEGAL information about MySQL.David Axmark5 Dec
Re: [OT] LEGAL information about MySQL.Pae Choi30 Nov
RE: [OT] LEGAL information about MySQL.David Brodbeck2 Dec
Re: LEGAL information about MySQL.Mark2 Dec
  • Re: LEGAL information about MySQL.Michael T. Babcock3 Dec