List:Internals« Previous MessageNext Message »
From:Paul Repacholi Date:February 15 2001 8:32pm
Subject:Re: transparent query direction
View as plain text  
> How is it more secure that just opening MySQL port on the master,
> and restricting the privileges inside MySQL on the master? The only
> extra benefit I see is that you cannot exploit the protocol
> vulnerabilities on a low level.  Otherwise, you can run all the same
> queries by proxy through the slave as you would directly on the
> master.

Because you also expose the host to your originating network. Also
consider the case of the client and server in 192.168 nets. Different
nets. A proxy with forwarding turned off can stradle the nets to give
access to the server for MySQL. If you route, hell would break loose!

The server machine can be running more that MySQL, and you may not
wish to expose that.

Also, it is far less pain to put all the smarts in the proxy, and have
no changes to the clients at all. That can be tested, all the clients
out there can't. If the client side want's to use the multi-server
stuff, then it can move after the server-proxy has been debugged and
cleaned up.

-- 
Paul Repacholi                               1 Crescent Rd.,
+61 (08) 9257-1001                           Kalamunda.
                                             West Australia 6076
Raw, Cooked or Well-done, it's all half baked.
Thread
transparent query directionHroi Sigurdsson14 Feb
  • Re: transparent query directionRussell E Glaue14 Feb
  • Re: transparent query directionSasha Pachev15 Feb
    • Re: transparent query directionHroi Sigurdsson15 Feb
      • Re: transparent query directionPaul Repacholi15 Feb
      • Re: transparent query directionSasha Pachev15 Feb
    • Re: transparent query directionJeremy D. Zawodny15 Feb
      • Re: transparent query directionSasha Pachev15 Feb
        • Re: transparent query directionPaul Repacholi15 Feb
          • Re: transparent query directionSasha Pachev15 Feb
            • Re: transparent query directionPaul Repacholi16 Feb
        • Re: transparent query directionJeremy D. Zawodny21 Feb
          • Re: transparent query directionSasha Pachev21 Feb
            • Re: transparent query directionHroi Sigurdsson21 Feb
              • Re: transparent query directionSasha Pachev21 Feb
                • Re: transparent query directionHroi Sigurdsson21 Feb
                  • Re: transparent query directionSasha Pachev22 Feb
                    • Re: transparent query directionMichael Widenius3 Mar
                      • Re: transparent query directionSasha Pachev5 Mar
  • Re: transparent query directionPaul Cadach5 Mar
    • Re: transparent query directionSasha Pachev5 Mar
  • Re: transparent query directionPaul Cadach5 Mar
    • Re: transparent query directionSasha Pachev5 Mar
  • Re: transparent query directionPaul Cadach6 Mar
  • Re: transparent query directionPaul Cadach7 Mar
  • Re: transparent query directionPaul Cadach7 Mar
  • Re: transparent query directionPaul Cadach7 Mar
Re: transparent query directionMichael Widenius5 Mar
Re: transparent query directionHeikki Tuuri7 Mar