List:Internals« Previous MessageNext Message »
From:Jay Pipes Date:September 8 2010 4:09pm
Subject:Re: [STYLE] use true/false in C++, not TRUE/FALSE
View as plain text  
On Wed, Sep 8, 2010 at 11:36 AM, Michael Widenius <monty@stripped> wrote:
>
> Hi!
>
>>>>>> "MARK" == MARK CALLAGHAN <mdcallag@stripped> writes:
>
> <cut>
>
> MARK> That isn't the problem. The problem is when I read frequently
> MARK> undocumented header files.
> MARK> my_bool do_this();
>
> MARK> The standard used by libc and others is to return an int with 0 as
> MARK> success and != 0 as an error. MySQL is the only system on which I have
> MARK> worked that uses bool and my_bool for this.
>
> In other words, the standard is to return TRUE for errors and FALSE
> for success, which you found confusing earlier.

No.  The standard is to return 0 for success, and something other than
0 for errors.  Mark was pretty clear about that.

In all C code I've worked with, the program defines some constant such
as SUCCESS to be 0 and then non-zero returns are constants
representing error codes.  MySQL returning TRUE as 0 and FALSE as 1 is
the ONLY system I've ever seen that does that (tries to have an
unsigned char behave like C++'s bool type).  And that is why there is
a complaint that it is non-standard.

Regards,

jay
Thread
[STYLE] use true/false in C++, not TRUE/FALSEGuilhem Bichot26 Aug
  • Re: [STYLE] use true/false in C++, not TRUE/FALSERoy Lyseng26 Aug
  • Re: [STYLE] use true/false in C++, not TRUE/FALSEMARK CALLAGHAN26 Aug
    • Re: [STYLE] use true/false in C++, not TRUE/FALSEGuilhem Bichot31 Aug
      • Re: [STYLE] use true/false in C++, not TRUE/FALSEMARK CALLAGHAN31 Aug
        • Re: [STYLE] use true/false in C++, not TRUE/FALSEGuilhem Bichot31 Aug
          • Re: [STYLE] use true/false in C++, not TRUE/FALSEJay Pipes31 Aug
            • Re: [STYLE] use true/false in C++, not TRUE/FALSEDavi Arnaut31 Aug
              • Re: [STYLE] use true/false in C++, not TRUE/FALSEJay Pipes31 Aug
                • Re: [STYLE] use true/false in C++, not TRUE/FALSEDavi Arnaut31 Aug
                  • Re: [STYLE] use true/false in C++, not TRUE/FALSEMARK CALLAGHAN31 Aug
                    • Re: [STYLE] use true/false in C++, not TRUE/FALSEDavi Arnaut31 Aug
                      • Re: [STYLE] use true/false in C++, not TRUE/FALSEMARK CALLAGHAN31 Aug
                        • Re: [STYLE] use true/false in C++, not TRUE/FALSERoy Lyseng31 Aug
                          • Re: [STYLE] use true/false in C++, not TRUE/FALSEMARK CALLAGHAN31 Aug
                            • Re: [STYLE] use true/false in C++, not TRUE/FALSEMichael Widenius8 Sep
                              • Re: [STYLE] use true/false in C++, not TRUE/FALSEJay Pipes8 Sep
                          • RE: [STYLE] use true/false in C++, not TRUE/FALSEVladislav Vaintroub31 Aug
                            • Re: [STYLE] use true/false in C++, not TRUE/FALSERoy Lyseng31 Aug
                            • Re: [STYLE] use true/false in C++, not TRUE/FALSEDavi Arnaut31 Aug
                              • Re: [STYLE] use true/false in C++, not TRUE/FALSEMichael Widenius8 Sep
                                • Re: [STYLE] use true/false in C++, not TRUE/FALSEDavi Arnaut8 Sep
                                  • RE: [STYLE] use true/false in C++, not TRUE/FALSEVladislav Vaintroub8 Sep
                        • Re: [STYLE] use true/false in C++, not TRUE/FALSEMichael Widenius8 Sep
                      • Re: [STYLE] use true/false in C++, not TRUE/FALSEKonstantin Osipov8 Sep
                        • Re: [STYLE] use true/false in C++, not TRUE/FALSEMats Kindahl8 Sep
                          • Re: [STYLE] use true/false in C++, not TRUE/FALSETor Didriksen8 Sep
                            • Re: [STYLE] use true/false in C++, not TRUE/FALSEMats Kindahl8 Sep
                              • RE: [STYLE] use true/false in C++, not TRUE/FALSEVladislav Vaintroub8 Sep
                                • Re: [STYLE] use true/false in C++, not TRUE/FALSEMats Kindahl8 Sep
                              • Re: [STYLE] use true/false in C++, not TRUE/FALSETor Didriksen8 Sep
                                • Re: [STYLE] use true/false in C++, not TRUE/FALSEMats Kindahl8 Sep
                  • Re: [STYLE] use true/false in C++, not TRUE/FALSEJay Pipes31 Aug
        • Re: [STYLE] use true/false in C++, not TRUE/FALSEMichael Widenius8 Sep
      • Re: [STYLE] use true/false in C++, not TRUE/FALSEMARK CALLAGHAN31 Aug
  • Re: [STYLE] use true/false in C++, not TRUE/FALSEMats Kindahl27 Aug
    • Re: [STYLE] use true/false in C++, not TRUE/FALSEMichael Widenius8 Sep