List:Internals« Previous MessageNext Message »
From:Michael Widenius Date:October 20 2009 11:27pm
Subject:re: Style proposal [Re: Coding style changes of 2009-06-26 now in the
guidelines]
View as plain text  
Hi!

>>>>> "Ingo" == Ingo Strüwing <Ingo.Struewing@stripped> writes:

Ingo> Hi Mark,
Ingo> thank you. I added it to the list of pending proposals:
Ingo> http://forge.mysql.com/wiki/Coding_Style#Pending_propsals

Ingo> MARK CALLAGHAN, 19.10.2009 17:07:

Ingo> ...
>> I don't expect existing code to be changed. But it would be nice for
>> people to slowly fix things when they edit code. My requests are:
>> 1) Use Unix style for functions (return type is int, 0 == success).
>> The current rule doesn't mention the return type. Do not use
>> bool/my_bool for this with FALSE==errror and TRUE==success in place of
>> 1.
>> 2) Use _Bool for my_bool on platforms that support C99
>> 3) Do not use the literals 0 and 1 in place of FALSE and TRUE

Then add also as a pending proposal to keep the current code style
convention.  I would also suggest that you never accept a code style
convention that is not accepted by those that are affected by it
(I those that produced code to MySQL or it's variants).

Regards,
Monty


Thread
Coding style changes of 2009-06-26 now in the guidelinesIngo Strüwing17 Oct
  • Re: Coding style changes of 2009-06-26 now in the guidelinesMARK CALLAGHAN17 Oct
    • Re: Coding style changes of 2009-06-26 now in the guidelinesMichael Widenius18 Oct
      • Re: Coding style changes of 2009-06-26 now in the guidelinesMARK CALLAGHAN18 Oct
        • Re: Coding style changes of 2009-06-26 now in the guidelinesMichael Widenius18 Oct
          • Re: Coding style changes of 2009-06-26 now in the guidelinesJay Pipes18 Oct
          • Re: Coding style changes of 2009-06-26 now in the guidelinesMARK CALLAGHAN18 Oct
            • Re: Coding style changes of 2009-06-26 now in the guidelinesMichael Widenius19 Oct
    • Re: Coding style changes of 2009-06-26 now in the guidelinesIngo Strüwing19 Oct
      • Re: Coding style changes of 2009-06-26 now in the guidelinesMats Kindahl19 Oct
        • RE: Coding style changes of 2009-06-26 now in the guidelinesVladislav Vaintroub19 Oct
          • Re: Coding style changes of 2009-06-26 now in the guidelinesMats Kindahl19 Oct
            • RE: Coding style changes of 2009-06-26 now in the guidelinesVladislav Vaintroub19 Oct
            • Re: Coding style changes of 2009-06-26 now in the guidelinesRoy Lyseng19 Oct
          • RE: Coding style changes of 2009-06-26 now in the guidelinesMichael Widenius21 Oct
      • Re: Coding style changes of 2009-06-26 now in the guidelinesMARK CALLAGHAN19 Oct
        • Style proposal [Re: Coding style changes of 2009-06-26 now in theguidelines]Ingo Strüwing19 Oct
          • re: Style proposal [Re: Coding style changes of 2009-06-26 now in theguidelines]Michael Widenius21 Oct
            • Re: Style proposal [Re: Coding style changes of 2009-06-26 now in theguidelines]Ingo Strüwing21 Oct
              • Re: Style proposal [Re: Coding style changes of 2009-06-26 now in theguidelines]Michael Widenius21 Oct
                • Re: Style proposal [Re: Coding style changes of 2009-06-26 now in the guidelines]MARK CALLAGHAN21 Oct
                  • Re: Style proposal [Re: Coding style changes of 2009-06-26 now in the guidelines]Michael Widenius21 Oct
                  • Re: Style proposal [Re: Coding style changes of 2009-06-26 now in theguidelines]Konstantin Osipov23 Oct
                    • Re: Style proposal [Re: Coding style changes of 2009-06-26 now in theguidelines]Jay Pipes23 Oct
                • Re: Style proposal [Re: Coding style changes of 2009-06-26 now in theguidelines]Ingo Strüwing22 Oct
                  • Re: Style proposal [Re: Coding style changes of 2009-06-26 now in theguidelines]Michael Widenius22 Oct
                    • Re: Style proposal [Re: Coding style changes of 2009-06-26 now in theguidelines]Ingo Strüwing22 Oct
                      • Re: Style proposal [Re: Coding style changes of 2009-06-26 now in theguidelines]Michael Widenius23 Oct
                    • Re: Style proposal [Re: Coding style changes of 2009-06-26 now in the guidelines]MARK CALLAGHAN23 Oct
                      • Re: Style proposal [Re: Coding style changes of 2009-06-26 now in the guidelines]Michael Widenius24 Oct
        • Re: Coding style changes of 2009-06-26 now in the guidelinesMichael Widenius21 Oct
          • Re: Coding style changes of 2009-06-26 now in the guidelinesMARK CALLAGHAN21 Oct
            • Re: Coding style changes of 2009-06-26 now in the guidelinesMichael Widenius21 Oct