List:Internals« Previous MessageNext Message »
From:Martin Friebe Date:March 21 2007 12:14pm
Subject:Re: review of patch for Bug#27175: "invalid column attributes in
create/alter table"
View as plain text  
Hi Chad,

I have attached a new version of the patch. I can upload it to the bug, 
if it is ok.

I have rewritten most comments, done all the missing line breaks, and 
adjusted the alignment.

Comments:
I left the @brief style in doxygen for now, as I believe the discussion 
is ongoing.
But I collected most of the information on the actual method, and added 
references to it.

Alignment:
I replaced most tabs by spaces, all I found about tabs, is that they are 
8 spaces.
The only mention of tabs on the style guide is in the emacs/vim settings.
So I wasn't sure about the preference between spaces and tabs?
(If any tabs are left, they should align at 8 spaces)

One thing I left unchanged: "type2"
Postfix numbers to identifiers are used throughout the sql_yacc.yy file.
Also type2 is somehow "private" to type. It must not be used from 
outside type.
It follows the naming convention of "create", "create2", "create2a",...

Best Regards
Martin

Chad MILLER wrote:
>
> On 20 Mar 2007, at 18:35, Martin Friebe wrote:
>> Just noting the latest tag on the bug, out of interest:
>> Is it the overall concept of the patch, or due to the coment below 
>> (and an implied expectation to me, of uploading a "corrected" patch)?
>
> The tag is just my way of noting whether I have something to do or 
> whether I'm waiting for something.  I'll almost certainly apply your 
> next patch when I receive it.
>
> - chad
>
>
>
>>
>
> -- 
> Chad Miller, Software Developer                         chad@stripped
> MySQL Inc., www.mysql.com
> Orlando, Florida, USA                                13-20z,  UTC-0400
> Office: +1 408 213 6740                         sip:6740@stripped
>
>


Attachment: [text/x-patch] column_spec.patch
Thread
review of patch for Bug#27175: "invalid column attributes in create/alter table"Chad MILLER19 Mar
  • Re: review of patch for Bug#27175: "invalid column attributes in create/alter table"Jim Winstead19 Mar
    • Re: review of patch for Bug#27175: "invalid column attributes increate/alter table"Jay Pipes20 Mar
      • Re: review of patch for Bug#27175: "invalid column attributes increate/alter table"David Shrewsbury20 Mar
      • "autobrief" in doxygen, was Re: review of patch for Bug#27175: "invalid column attributes in create/alter table"Chad MILLER20 Mar
  • Re: review of patch for Bug#27175: "invalid column attributes increate/alter table"David Shrewsbury20 Mar
  • Re: review of patch for Bug#27175: "invalid column attributes increate/alter table"Martin Friebe20 Mar
Re: review of patch for Bug#27175: "invalid column attributes increate/alter table"Martin Friebe21 Mar